Hobie Adventure or Ocean Kayak Trident 15?

I checked the later out today and really liked it.  I like the Hobie peddle concept but, since ALL my fishing is off the central Cal. coast, don't want to look like shark bait with those fin-like peddles.  What to do?  Despite looking like a fat, elephant seal in a Hobie Adventure, I'm leaning towards that brand.  Which brand is more stable and ocean friendly when the wind kicks in?  Can someone convince me not to buy the Trident 15? 

Thanks, Eric

Buy the T-15!

Go demo them both at lunch on a windy day. See which one sends you home hungry.

are you true to your handle as a "whitesharkseeker"?  If so, then your answer is pretty obvious!

I think the adventure is better in the wind and plenty stable.  At least it was stable for me. I felt it paddled as well as my T13 did.

Off the top of my head I only know of one attack on a Hobie and 2-3 on traditional yaks. I sincerely doubt type of yak has anything to do with it. A GWS will bite anything out there.

I think they are very comparable in stability. Only one way to know how it works for you, demo 'em.

Z

The fins making you like food is a bunch of bunk.  Sitting on the surface of the water in a kayak makes you look like food! 

I have a P13 and a Hobie Adventure.  I will be taking the Hobie out for the maiden voyage this Saturday, so will be able to give a better review/speed/range comparison.

Rigging the Hobie shows it is just as well built as my Ocean Kayak.  They both have points I love and dislike.  The Hobie is harder to rig and takes more thought. The Ocean kayak is better for diving as it paddles into the kelp.  The Hobie has more speed and range.  The Ocean Kayak is cheaper! 

My main reason for the Hobie was the speed, range and ability to troll.  Trying the paddle and troll for Salmon and Halibut was a pain in the P13.  The larger divers and weights made me go in circles against a heavy current.  A rudder would have helped a lot.  With the Hobie I will be able to peddle and release my line at the same time.  I like to paddle, but my bad back makes me pay for a hard day of fishing.  I hope the Hobie rectifies that some!  I went with the Adventure as it is supposed to paddle nicely, as well as the peddle option. 

When i finally decided to upgrade to a faster boat I went back and forth between the Tarpon 160 and Hobie Adventure.  I think the faster boats lead to less effort to distance traveled, more sea worthy, and more comfort, although a loss in stability (which is a learned skill).  The T-15 is also a fast boat, so you would not be loosing much there.  You may check out the new Prowler Ultra!  That is also a very nice ride!

I would say to weight your options and style of fishing, as you can really go wrong with either boat.  If you need speed and long rang, the Hobie probably is better suited.  If you are river fishing or kelp fishing in the heavy stuff, the Ocean Kayak would be better.  I admittedly like the rod pods and rigging options on the T-15!  I would make a list, weighing the plus and negatives of each boat.  Pick the one with the most pluses!

Hope I helped, buy reading back through my post I think I just muddied the water nicely for you 

Matt

 I have took my 15 out in some nasty weather an it handled very well. I will admit this though, a hobie will flat out smoke any kayak that is paddled

Get an X-Factor.   

Get the hobie for sure without a doubt.

I think MattS has it. You need both 

I was admiring HamachiJohn's Adventure a couple weeks ago (I want one), while he was looking at my Tarpon and regretting selling his.

If you're going to do a lot of trolling, or a lot of distance (a lot),  I would think the Adventure would be great.

Rockfish fishing, in the kelp, surf, etc...  paddling is a non issue, and maybe advantageous not having to deal with the mirage drive.

After that it just blurs into what feels good I think   

That's like asking which of your children is more talented.
I fish out of both, but the adventure is my main yak - I like Matt's response though. Sorry to babble and not being very helpful

Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL using Tapatalk

My main reason for the Hobie was the speed, range and ability to troll.  Trying the paddle and troll for Salmon and Halibut was a pain in the P13.  The larger divers and weights made me go in circles against a heavy current.  A rudder would have helped a lot.  With the Hobie I will be able to peddle and release my line at the same time.  I like to paddle, but my bad back makes me pay for a hard day of fishing.  I hope the Hobie rectifies that some!  I went with the Adventure as it is supposed to paddle nicely, as well as the peddle option. 

I am not being a smart ass but Hobie's have Pedals not Peddles.  This is pretty common mistake in this site including myself in the past and was likewise corrected. 

From dictionary.com: Pedal is a leverlike part worked by the foot to supply power in various mechanisms. 
Peddle - To carry (small articles, goods, wares, etc.) from place to place for sale at retail. 

First off, welcome to the madness Eric!  I was surprised that you kept your handle from coastside!

My first kayak was a P13 Angler and I swapped it out for a Revo after a few months.  The main reason for the change was so that I could concentrate on fishing more... and I didn't have to stop my upper body workout to prepare for the weekend paddle.  I'm glad I made the switch but I might have done things a bit differently if I had the chance (prob. an adventure island).  The main difference between the two is that I'm able to spend more time on the water, especially when conditions turn for the worse.  This is invaluable given the amount of time it takes to prepare for a fishing trip and the limited fishing opportunities (nasty conditions within reason of course).

CCK was mentioned on the other site... that's where I purchased mine and I got a great deal.  It's a good place to give the pedals a try.

welcome over from coastside...

I've got a P15, and have had paddle yaks for a decade...now that my P15 is getting a bit beat, I fairly certain my next yak will be an adventure (adventure islander!).  I don't have the back issues others have mentioned, but i spend a LOT of time trolling (stripers, halibut, salmon when we have a season), and working rips for stripers. It is easy to troll paddling, only a bit of a pain, but trying to hold in a rip is really really hard. I've convinced myself that i can simply slay 'em at RedRock if i can hold my drift...  GRIN.

paddle/pedal both....then decide. Saving that pile of cash with the OK is a HUGE factor.

are you true to your handle as a "whitesharkseeker"?  If so, then your answer is pretty obvious!

I think the adventure is better in the wind and plenty stable.  At least it was stable for me. I felt it paddled as well as my T13 did.

Thanks so much for the excellent comments, folks!  Yes, my handle represents the fact that I have participated in many white shark tagging expeditions (from a boat larger than a 'yak).  Love sharks but seen too many bite decoys and kayaks tend to look like a big lure!  Ha, ha...still looking forward to kayaking!

Thanks to all, Eric