Are Canoes OK for AOTY fishing?

You have got to be fucking kidding me.

Oh my I was just waiting for this

Tony, I have a WS pamlico tandem that is just awesome. Its 13.5 ft and real stable. Linelle and I use it in the sierras. fast too. Its yours anytime you want to use it. Buddy. The 2 year old can sit right between you guys. Thats a sit inside model. real comfy and dry.

I have a WS Pam 120 and have a child seat for it believe it or not. You can use it if you like also.

NCKA is our name. We are anglers in Kayaks. = REMEMBER THAT & NEVER FORGET or QUESTION IT.

NCKA is our name. We are anglers in Kayaks. = REMEMBER THAT & NEVER FORGET or QUESTION IT.

  If that is the case than why all the dive reports?
(just having fun)

See Ya Soon

NCKA is our name. We are anglers in Kayaks. = REMEMBER THAT & NEVER FORGET or QUESTION IT.

  If that is the case than why all the dive reports?
(just having fun)

See Ya Soon

dont they get there (most of the time) by yak??  and your right, but it's more about a Family of SameTypes&Thoughts(most of the time) 

NCKA is our name. We are anglers in Kayaks. = REMEMBER THAT & NEVER FORGET or QUESTION IT.

  If that is the case than why all the dive reports?
(just having fun)

See Ya Soon

So you guys can see whats not biting your hooks 



.....and before anyone asks.....no you cannot enter speared fish.  End of story 

You have got to be fucking kidding me.

Oh my I was just waiting for this

x2
 

not part of the com either but if a guy in a canoe is not gonna count then well a hobie shouldnt count...

They should also disqualify yaks that sink. It says human powered, not tidal powered. 

The committee should handle this just like the courts do: Refuse to respond to the question until there is a complaint, then rule on the complaint based on the current rules. The current rules seem clear enough that there hasn't been a problem yet. So, why not wait until somebody submits a catch from something other than a kayak, then see if anybody files a complaint with the rules committee before we get wrapped around the axel on a hypothetical case.

Otherwise, you could get caught up playing "what if" with the rules for the rest of your life. Just my .02 

But my initial reaction when I read this post was the same as Craig's 
In the meantime, you guys need to go fishing. You have no excuse! I have a foot of snow on the ground and the lake shores are iced over!

Speaking for myself, and in all seriousness it brought up a good question:  What is a kayak?

Kinda has me stumped.  We all know what a kayak is, but try to put it into words.

Best I can come up with is "a small boat propelled by double-bladed paddle".

Speaking for myself, and in all seriousness it brought up a good question:  What is a kayak?

Kinda has me stumped.  We all know what a kayak is, but try to put it into words.

Best I can come up with is "a small boat propelled by double-bladed paddle".

which may or may not be made out of reeds or other natural materials 

But my initial reaction when I read this post was the same as Craig's 
In the meantime, you guys need to go fishing. You have no excuse! I have a foot of snow on the ground and the lake shores are iced over!

+1

Refuse to respond to the question until there is a complain

If the question is w/in the realm of reasonable, it deserves an answer. It's not right to ignore it and then say "no" after he posts a fish.

I have a foot of snow on the ground and the lake shores are iced over!

Are you implying that is some sort of an excuse not to fish?   

Kinda has me stumped.  We all know what a kayak is, but try to put it into words.

Kayaks are like pornography, you know one when you see it 

A kayak is a canoe with spaces designed into the hull that are intended to remain dry/water tight.

Fishfarmer, then this is not a kayak?

A kayak is a canoe with spaces designed into the hull that are intended to remain dry/water tight.

Fishfarmer, then this is not a kayak?

Make with reeds, reeds are hollow (intended to be water tight)... so sure. 

Really. Isn't that essentially the difference between most human powered vessels and yaks? We could get nit-picky about tube floats, and such, I guess, but essentially that's it. If you capsize a canoe it sinks. If you capsize that guy's boat-made-of-reeds it floats. A couple big air spaces, thousands of little ones, I don't see a functional difference. It goes along with the "be able to roll" idea, I guess, w/o having to be able to roll.   

Ben