Prohibited from Retrieving Deer from Private Property

September 27, 2012

Question: I recently shot a doe with my A31 tag in Los Angeles County (Archery Only-Either Sex). It appeared to be a lethal shot from 22 yards with decent shot placement. I tracked the blood to a privately owned ranch 100 yards away. I stopped tracking it when it appeared she went onto the ranch property. I then approached the ranch manager to get permission to continue tracking my deer. The owner initially agreed but after one of her coworkers talked to her, she retracted her permission (approximately 10 minutes from the time we spoke in her office). She requested that we leave her property at once as she didn’t want people to think they approved of hunting. I didn’t have enough time to locate my deer and left broken-hearted.

I don’t like seeing animals die or suffer for no reason. I would never have shot if I would have known I couldn’t recover her. I believe I did everything legal and correct but it shouldn’t be right that a deer goes to waste because of the bias of a property manager.

Is there anything I could have done to recover my deer? Do I have any rights or is there anyone I could have contacted? I’m still sick over the situation. (Luke G., Loma Linda)

Answer: It’s unfortunate that this happened. Although the law prevents one from wasting the deer, the law does not permit the trespass to retrieve it. Perhaps, if you’d contacted the local game warden, they may have been able to contact the ranch manager or owner for some possible assistance to prevent the deer from going to waste.

According to Department of Fish and Game Lt. Todd Tognazzini, when archery hunting it is recommended to hunt farther from private property boundaries to avoid this type of problem as deer taken with archery usually travel farther after a lethal wound than those shot with a rifle. Tognazzini says he has never been refused when a fresh and legitimate blood trail is found leaving public land onto private property.

You should mail the ranger an envelope full of gold bond foot powder. What a friggin' jerk.

The Ranger had/has nothing to do with someones private property.  Why hold anything against the Ranger? 

Ranch Manager.

Ranch Manager.

That's where I was going....

Yes, ranch manager. You know what I meant!!

Yeah, mailing a ranch manager an envelope full of white powder - great idea.  Such a problem that its worth breaking federal laws for.

I was kidding. 

Yeah, mailing a ranch manager an envelope full of white powder - great idea.  Such a problem that its worth breaking federal laws for.

When did you become a wet blanket sourpuss.

Killjoy.

Maybe you were just insinuating that the ranch owner had smelly feet...? Sounds like a good defense to me.