Art,
Great idea.  $5 is bait money so that shouldn't break anyones bank.  

Joel should be forced to pay $20, because he fishes at least 4 times the average person.

Stuart

Cabbies definitely have very delicate meat of the RCG family.  Greenling are very delicate too except they are SUPER BONY, therefore I toss them back.  
To me its a toss up between a cab a ling, but given that you typically get more meat from a ling, I'd lean in that direction.  I too believe the texture of all the other's is not quite as delicate as these two fish.

One of my least favorite fish on the table is halibut.  Its ok cooked (a little too dry and bland), but I like it better raw.


Stuart