NorCal Kayak Anglers

General => CA Regulations => Topic started by: JamesM on February 08, 2018, 04:13:26 PM

Title: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: JamesM on February 08, 2018, 04:13:26 PM
Is 2nd rod allowed in San Pablo Bay? Assuming 2nd rod stamp purchased. Thanks!
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: JamesM on February 08, 2018, 04:21:11 PM
I think I just found the answer...•While fishing in San Francisco and San Pablo bays you can only use one fishing line with no more than three separate hooks or lures.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: E Kayaker on February 08, 2018, 05:49:18 PM
I think I just found the answer...•While fishing in San Francisco and San Pablo bays you can only use one fishing line with no more than three separate hooks or lures.
Keep in mind the definition of San Francisco and San Pablo bays includes the tributaries. You are also limited to one pole in the Napa River for example. I don't know if it was changed but I believe you're allowed two poles when fishing in the bay from a pier.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: simplycook on February 08, 2018, 08:14:11 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier. 
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: krusty on February 08, 2018, 08:53:24 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: E Kayaker on February 08, 2018, 09:04:19 PM
When I discussed it with DFG a while back they said fishing from the pier had different rules.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: Eddie on February 08, 2018, 09:07:37 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
2 Rods(lines) on the piers, Mcnears, paradise, baker, chrissy field...
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: krusty on February 08, 2018, 10:38:26 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
2 Rods(lines) on the piers, Mcnears, paradise, baker, chrissy field...

Where does it say you are allowed to fish with 2 lines? The 2 rods on pier rule only apply for crabbing.

Quote
28.65 (a) San Francisco Bay, as described in Section 27.00, where only one line with not more than three hooks may be used.
(b) On public piers, no person shall use more than two rods and lines, two hand lines, or two nets, traps or other appliances used to take crabs.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: Eddie on February 08, 2018, 10:54:13 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
2 Rods(lines) on the piers, Mcnears, paradise, baker, chrissy field...

Where does it say you are allowed to fish with 2 lines? The 2 rods on pier rule only apply for crabbing.

Quote
28.65 (a) San Francisco Bay, as described in Section 27.00, where only one line with not more than three hooks may be used.
(b) On public piers, no person shall use more than two rods and lines, two hand lines, or two nets, traps or other appliances used to take crabs.
I read that as separate items.  We have been approached by cdfw at mcnears and paradise and there is never a question about 2 rods per person.  I'm paranoid throwing a cast net or having a bait trap in the water with 2 rods in so I pull one during that time.  One sabiki going on the pier and one with live bait is also common.  Two rods and lines does not sound like crab gear.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: simplycook on February 08, 2018, 10:59:29 PM
Eddie is correct. I've been approached at nearly every pier inside the Bay and this was never as issue.
It is read as separate items. Two rods or handlines refers to fin fish and the two nets, traps or other appliances refer to crabs.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: Eddie on February 08, 2018, 11:01:38 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
2 Rods(lines) on the piers, Mcnears, paradise, baker, chrissy field...

Where does it say you are allowed to fish with 2 lines? The 2 rods on pier rule only apply for crabbing.

Quote
28.65 (a) San Francisco Bay, as described in Section 27.00, where only one line with not more than three hooks may be used.
(b) On public piers, no person shall use more than two rods and lines, two hand lines, or two nets, traps or other appliances used to take crabs.
I read that as separate items.  We have been approached by cdfw at mcnears and paradise and there is never a question about 2 rods per person.  I'm paranoid throwing a cast net or having a bait trap in the water with 2 rods in so I pull one during that time.  One sabiki going on the pier and one with live bait is also common.  Two rods and lines does not sound like crab gear.
I remember getting questioned not at a public pier and I was using two rods in china camp at a dock in a tributary.  I was truly ignorant because I figured it was a public dock so I justified two rods.  As we were wrapping up the dark green badged truck came flying down and the questioning began.  He asked how many rods I was using.  He asked where I usually fish.  I told him Mcnears, Paradise, Bodega Jetty, Bon tempe...all two rod legal spots.  I told him I was using two to finish up using my bait.  It was New Years day and he gave me a break because I told the truth and he said he saved me a 700.00 $ ticket.  I was truly grateful.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: simplycook on February 08, 2018, 11:28:59 PM
Eddie, you got lucky!  $700 ticket could have easily bought you another kayak!

Again, that's why I mentioned "public fishing pier". 
Not all docks, piers, or jetties are recognized as county/state public fishing piers.  If they're not, then they fall under the same regulations as fishing from shore.  1 rod/line/rig/trap and license required. 
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: simplycook on February 08, 2018, 11:30:43 PM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

As for when the 2nd rod stamp comes into effect for inland waters, I can't remember if it's east of the Carquinez Bridge or east or the Benicia bridge. 
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: E Kayaker on February 09, 2018, 05:33:36 AM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

As for when the 2nd rod stamp comes into effect for inland waters, I can't remember if it's east of the Carquinez Bridge or east or the Benicia bridge.
Carquinez bridge. In the image I posted above, it is clearly stated, in the regs not so much. I think they decided since piers in ocean waters in general are limited to two poles instead of unlimited like most ocean waters they would allow two poles everywhere including in the bay where normally it's one pole max.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: E Kayaker on February 09, 2018, 07:21:57 AM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

That is also incorrect. You can fish off a fishing pier without a license, but you still have to follow the fishing regulations, which means only 1 rod in San Francisco and San Pablo bay.
2 Rods(lines) on the piers, Mcnears, paradise, baker, chrissy field...

Where does it say you are allowed to fish with 2 lines? The 2 rods on pier rule only apply for crabbing.

Quote
28.65 (a) San Francisco Bay, as described in Section 27.00, where only one line with not more than three hooks may be used.
(b) On public piers, no person shall use more than two rods and lines, two hand lines, or two nets, traps or other appliances used to take crabs.

It isn't spelled out in the regs. There are two conflicting regs and they decided to have the two poles on piers overrule the one pole in the bay. Just one of the many quirks of the regs.
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: Eddie on February 09, 2018, 07:27:16 AM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

As for when the 2nd rod stamp comes into effect for inland waters, I can't remember if it's east of the Carquinez Bridge or east or the Benicia bridge.
Carquinez
Title: Re: 2nd rod in San Pablo Bay?
Post by: simplycook on February 09, 2018, 08:04:22 AM
That 2nd rod stamp is only allowed for inland waters and east of the Carquinez bridge (I believe). 
I run into so many guys who misunderstand this.  Only way to use two rods/rigs/traps in the SF and SP Bay would be off a public fishing pier.

As for when the 2nd rod stamp comes into effect for inland waters, I can't remember if it's east of the Carquinez Bridge or east or the Benicia bridge.
Carquinez bridge. In the image I posted above, it is clearly stated, in the regs not so much. I think they decided since piers in ocean waters in general are limited to two poles instead of unlimited like most ocean waters they would allow two poles everywhere including in the bay where normally it's one pole max.

Thanks!